"Sociologist Philip Rieff, in The Triumph of the Therapeutic,
observed that institutions die when they can no longer communicate
their core values to the next generation in a convincing way. He said
this to support his contention (in 1966!) that Christianity was dying in
the West, because we Westerners have become hostile to the ascetic
spirit that is inextricable from authentic Christianity, and has been
from the beginning. As you know, I believe Rieff was right, and that his
being right is not something that traditional Christians should take
comfort in, except in this one way: a Christianity that does demand
something sacrificial from its followers is not only being true to the
nature of the religion, but is far more likely to engender the kind of
devotion that will endure through the therapeutic dark age. Aside from
its radical theological innovations that are impossible to harmonize
with Christianity as it was known for its first 1,900 years, Progressive
Christianity has fully embraced the therapeutic mindset, in the sense
that Rieff means. It is dying because it cannot convince young people to
embrace its values within the institutional churches. It can’t be
denied that many of the young do accept the social liberalism embraced
by the progressive churches, but it also can’t be denied that most of
them don’t see why they have to be part of a church to be socially
progressive.'
"Theological conservatives had better watch out with this. If you
raise up young people to believe that the truth of their theological
beliefs is determined by the quality of their emotional experience in
worship, you are undermining your foundations."
-Rod Dreher
No comments:
Post a Comment